I've been there twice now. The food has been amazing both times. Despite their extremely large selection, they seem to know how to cook everything pretty darn well.
However, the service has been erratic. The first time I went it took a server fifteen minutes to take our drink order. It got so bad that the hostess came and served us instead of the person she had previously told us was our server. It was very poor service.
The second time the service was impeccable. So overall I give them a 3 out of 5 for service and a 5 out of 5 for the food. That works out to 4 stars in my book. I am hopeful, though, that as I go there more times I will have more of the impeccable service.
We go there all the time. The food is great and we've always been happy with the service. I'd recommend it to anyone looking for a small sports bar like atmosphere with great food and a varied menu. We especially like to go there during the week, as opposed to weekends, simply because the crowds are thinner. Note: The backroom has huge booths and is nicely separated from the bar area.