Crime & Safety

Remains of 15 More Dogs Found at Muddy Paws Site in Deer Park

Prosecutor's motion to discover source of $25,000 bail posted for Diane Eldrup denied at hearing.

Assistant State’s Attorney Michael Mermel said 15 more dead dogs were found at the Muddy Paws site in Deer Park. That brings the total to 34 dogs and three birds suspected of being starved to death at the former rescue and boarding facility.

“The animals were so deteriorated. They were really just little piles of fur,” Mermel said in Lake County court.

At the April 11 hearing, Mermel said he would not file additional charges against Diane Eldrup, owner of Muddy Paws. Eldrup is charged with 19 counts of aggravated cruelty and 19 counts of animal torture.

Find out what's happening in Palatinewith free, real-time updates from Patch.

In a previous interview, co-prosecutor Suzanne Willett said additional charges would not strengthen the case

Eldrup and her attorney John Curnyn were in court for a hearing on bond resource. Mermel had filed a motion to determine the source of the $25,000 bond posted on Eldrup's behalf.

Find out what's happening in Palatinewith free, real-time updates from Patch.

Mermel argued that Eldrup did not have funds to post the $25,000 bail because her home had been foreclosed. He said Algonquin resident John Breseman posted the bail money with $8,000 in cash and a $17,000 cashier’s check.

Curnyn countered the motion, arguing that the law allowing discovery of bail funds was written for drug cases, where the funds were suspected of having been illegally obtained.

“This doesn’t meet intent; this is not a drug case,” Curnyn said.

Judge James Booras ruled in Curnyn's favor, rejecting the prosecution's motion.

The first 17 dogs, as well as three birds, were discovered dead from dehydration and starvation in December, after Kurt Eldrup, estranged husband of Diane Eldrup, called authorities to the home.

Prosecutors originally charged Diane Eldrup with 34 counts of aggravated cruelty and animal torture. In March, Kurt Eldrup returned to the home to retrieve belongings and discovered two more dead dogs. Diane Eldrup was charged with four more additional counts of aggravated cruelty and animal torture on March 23.

Kurt Eldrup told Patch that the 15 recently discovered dead dogs were piled up near an outside area where his son would have played.

Kurt Eldrup said he filed a complaint with DCFS, in 2008, because he was concerned about the hygiene of the Muddy Paws complex. He said his son smelled bad when he would pick him up for visitation. The complaint was investigated, but DCFS found no abuse. Kurt Eldrup could not go inside the Muddy Paws boarding facility/residence because Diane Eldrup had an order of protection against him.

The Department of Agriculture also investigated complaints of animal cruelty in 2008 and concluded the claims were unfounded, according to legal letters provided by Kurt Eldrup.

 The case against Diane Eldrup for aggravated cruelty and animal torture is set to go to trial on May 20.


Get more local news delivered straight to your inbox. Sign up for free Patch newsletters and alerts.

We’ve removed the ability to reply as we work to make improvements. Learn more here

To request removal of your name from an arrest report, submit these required items to arrestreports@patch.com.