D-211 Votes No On Video Of Meetings
The Township High School District 211 school board voted 4-3 Thursday against placing video of their meetings on the Web
Video of Township High School District 211 school board meetings will not make it on the district's website after school board members voted against the idea.
School board member Bill Roberston had proposed the district purchase two cameras, video school board proceedings and place the video on the district's website.
"Let's record the meetings with a two-camera system, keep it simple. Let's not go crazy with expenses but at the same time have a happy medium between quality and just getting the information out there," Robertson said.
Robertson capped the cost of his plan at $10,000. His proposal was a much more scaled down proposal compared to other options the school district had looked into.
District 211 Superintendent Nancy Robb delivered a report at the previous school board meeting that contained start-up cost estimates of $50,000 to $100,000 for systems that would involve as many as four cameras and allow the broadcast or live streaming of meetings.
School board member Anna Klimkowicz said she was supportive of Robertson's idea. Klimkowicz said that although board documents are online, discussions by board members are not.
"You don't see the passion and the discussion," Klimkowicz said. "That's where my heart is in regards to it."
Klimkowicz also said presentations at board meetings – about curriculum, academic programs, finances – should be better shared with the public.
"I just think it's so important to keep that communication open," she said.
However, school board member George Brandt said the school board is transparent in how it conducts its business. As for public interest, Brandt said "outlets like the Patch or the Daily Herald or the Tribune would already be doing this...If it was so easy and so cheap to do they would certainly sit here with a camera and post it."
Brandt said everything the board, including every check that is written, already is on the Internet. He said the motion was incomplete because it did not contain staff costs.
"I find no value in using public funds when it can be done privately," Brandt said.
Board member Edward Yung said he was concerned because part of the district is Spanish speaking and wondered whether the videos should be translated into Spanish or have subtitles.
"I'm not sure that we're really achieving what we should be achieving, making this thing totally open to the public," Yung said.
However, board member Mucia Burke pointed out that the school district does not translate documents it places online into Spanish.
Richard Gerber, Jung, Robert LeFevre, Jr. and Brandt voted against the motion. Robertson, Klimkowicz and Burke voted in favor of it.
M C
8:23 am on Friday, October 28, 2011
This is a perfect example of what happens when you put a room full of managers together. Next, they will spend a couple of hours trying to decide on which coffee should be prepared for them at their meetings. Maybe we will be lucky and they will determine they shouldn't drink coffee because it may offend the tea drinking people out here. I want to thank them for taking a giant leap backward in their efforts to go forward. They sound like our congress and senate. Their transparency is duly noted.
neatone
9:03 am on Friday, October 28, 2011
This is really shameful. There are many working parents who could benefit from viewing the meetings online. And posting documents online is not the same. The only reason someone would vote against this is because they do not want transparency and accountability!
Jim Wilson
9:53 am on Friday, October 28, 2011
Sad now that we can view District 15 and Village meetings. High priced Supers and administrators but District can't afford meeting tapes?
Must have something to hide.:)
Scott
3:08 pm on Friday, October 28, 2011
At least now we know who we're NOT voting for in the next election. We've cleaned up D15; now we have a new challenge ahead of us.
Cj money
11:23 pm on Friday, October 28, 2011
I agree Scott. Roberston has done what he said he would do from day one. At least he's in there for us, now we just need to clean up the others.